Data &
Technology
Research
Reports
Report Solutions
Reports Library
Actionable
Strategies
Free
Resources
Simple Backtest Calculator
Simple Seasonality Calculator
The Kelly Criterion Calculator
Sentiment Geo Map
Public Research Reports
Free Webinar
Pricing
Company
About
Meet Our Team
In the News
Testimonials
Client Success Stories
Contact
Log inLoginSign up
< BACK TO ALL REPORTS

Daily Report : Drawdown in energy stocks is the worst of any sector, ever

Jason Goepfert
2020-10-29
Energy stocks have lost 60% more from their highs than did the broader market. That's the worst of any sector going back to 1928. Usually, a sector's relative losses have stopped at about 35%. Other times a sector's investors suffered that much relative to the S&P 500, it outperformed over the next 1-3 years.
View/Print a PDF version of this Report

Headlines


Drawdown in energy stocks is the worst of any sector, ever: Energy stocks have lost 60% more from their highs than did the broader market. That's the worst of any sector going back to 1928. Usually, a sector's relative losses have stopped at about 35%. Other times a sector's investors suffered that much relative to the S&P 500, it outperformed over the next 1-3 years.

That was fast: A day after "fear" rose enough to push the VIX above 40, it fell back below. This shows that traders are only flirting with the potential for a sustained rout - most major declines see volatility spike and then stay high until the panic subsides. It's not foolproof, as it preceded big losses in September 2008 and March of this year. But 3 months later, only 1 out of 25 signals showed a loss greater than -3% in the S&P 500.

Bottom Line:

  • A positive environment favors becoming aggressive on signs of excessive pessimism.
  • Market environment (More info)
    PositivesNegatives
    1. Price pattern (barely)1. % of Stocks in Correction
    2. Moving averages2. Net New Highs / Lows
    3. McClellan Summation

    4. % Stocks > 200-Day
  • Sentiment / Breadth / Other
    PositivesNegatives
    1. Big up volume1. Confidence high and declining
    2. Surging small-caps2. Too much options speculation
    3. Surging tech stocks3. Equities high vs GDP, Assets
    4. Mar-May thrusts, recoveries4. IPO market too hot
    5. Excess liquidity is high
  • Other Sectors and Assets
    PositivesNegatives
    1. Energy (here, here, and here)1. Skewed tech (here and here)

    2. Dollar test

Smart / Dumb Money Confidence

Smart Money Confidence: 31% Dumb Money Confidence: 60%

Risk Levels

Stocks Short-Term

Stocks Medium-Term

Bonds

Crude Oil

Gold

Agriculture

Research

Drawdown in energy stocks is the worst of any sector, ever

BOTTOM LINE
Energy stocks have lost 60% more from their highs than did the broader market. That's the worst of any sector going back to 1928. Usually, a sector's relative losses have stopped at about 35%. Other times a sector's investors suffered that much relative to the S&P 500, it outperformed over the next 1-3 years.

FORECAST / TIMEFRAME
None

There have been two themes that got renewed interest this week, both dealing with drawdowns. The energy sector, and the value factor, have suffered massive losses relative to other sectors and factors, respectively.

We've already seen that energy has been one of the most consistently losing sectors out of any sector since 1928. It's also suffered one of the largest drawdowns. Looking at each sector's maximum loss from its latest multi-year peak can be instructive, but it's better to look at it relative to the drawdown of the broader S&P 500 index.

The charts below show just that. To be clear, this is each sector's maximum decline from a 3-year high, minus the drawdown in the S&P 500 index. So, it shows losses that investors suffered beyond what they would have been exposed to in the broader market.

From the charts, we can see that it's unusual for any sector over the past 90 years to suffer a drawdown that was 35% more than the drawdown in the S&P...except for energy's current malaise.

 The current drawdown in energy is now about 60% more than the S&P's, by far the worst of any sector in history. It exceeds the relative losses in tech after the internet bubble burst and devastation in financials following the Great Financial Crisis. Below, we zoom in on each individual sector once its relative drawdown neared or exceeded -35%.

When utilities suffered this much in 1934, the ratio of that sector to the broader S&P turned and went on a year-long recovery.

The only other time when energy dropped 35% more than the broader market was in 1982, which preceded a little more weakness, then years of outperformance.

Health care stocks suffered relative devastation in 1993, which marked the bottom for that sector versus the broader market.

When staples fell this much relative to the broader market in 2000, they turned immediately and enjoyed massive outperformance.

Materials stocks didn't quite fall more than 35% than the broader market in 2000, but got close, and then outperformed.

When tech stocks first dropped 35% more than the broader market in 2001, they briefly rebounded, then fell into a much more prolonged malaise.

Communication stocks mostly stabilized or outperformed once their relative drawdowns exceeded 35%.

Financials got hit hard during the financial crisis, but their relative losses weren't 35% worse than the broader market's until 2011. Unlike other sectors, this did not lead to outperformance in the year(s) ahead.

We can see this big shift in investor preferences in the past year among defensive and value stocks relative to cyclical and growth stocks. Defensive stocks dropped about 9% more from their highs than did the S&P, and value stocks about 15% more. Both are among the worst relative losses in 90 years for any of the factors.

The rout in energy stocks is historic, and maybe that's enough of a warning sign. No other sector has seen as much selling pressure in 90 years. Other times that selling pressure reached a lesser extreme, those sectors had a very strong tendency to outperform over the next 1-3 years. Energy hasn't done that and has only gone on to even further extremes.

That raises the chance of a "this time is different" scenario, the biggest extreme-can-always-get-more-extreme risk that contrary investors face. It seems unlikely that investors could suffer further relative losses in energy stocks, but that same thing could have been said 15% ago. The complete give-up in this sector should be a long-term positive, it just needs to see some stabilization for investors to realize things are morphing from bad to less bad.


Active Studies

Click here to view the Active Research on the site.
Time FrameBullishBearish
Short-Term00
Medium-Term48
Long-Term482

Indicators at Extremes

Click here to view on the site (% Extremes and "Excess" tabs on the dashboard).
% Showing Pessimism: 14%
Bullish for Stocks

NYSE Up Issues Ratio
NYSE High/Low Ratio
S&P 500 Down Pressure
VIX
Inverse ETF Volume
Mutual Fund Flow (no ETFs)
Rydex Beta Chase Index
Rydex Bull/Bear RSI Spread
Rydex Sector Breadth
VIX Term Structure
NYSE Up Volume Ratio
Insider Buy/Sell Seasonally Adj
% Showing Optimism: 33%
Bearish for Stocks

Smart Money / Dumb Money Confidence Spread
Smart Money Confidence
Short-term Optimism Index (Optix)
Dumb Money Confidence
% Showing Excess Optimism
NAAIM Exposure Index
Rydex Bearish Flow
Rydex Ratio
Rydex Money Market %
NYSE Arms Index
ROBO Put/Call Ratio
AIM (Advisor and Investor Model)
Options Speculation Index
Equity Hedging Index
Major Index Combo
NYSE Available Cash
Retail Money Market Ratio
Equity / Money Market Asset Ratio
Mutual Fund Cash Level

Portfolio

PositionDescriptionWeight %Added / ReducedDate
Stocks15.6% RSP, 10.1% VWO, 7.5% XLE, 5.1% PSCE38.2Added 5%2020-10-15
Bonds10% BND, 10% SCHP, 10% ANGL29.7Reduced 0.1%2020-10-02
CommoditiesGCC2.4Reduced 2.1%
2020-09-04
Precious MetalsGDX4.7Added 5%2020-09-09
Special Situations0.0Reduced 5%2020-10-02
Cash25.0
Updates (Changes made today are underlined)

After the September swoon wrung some of the worst of the speculation out of stocks, there are some signs that it's returning, especially in the options market. It's helped to push Dumb Money Confidence above 70%.

A big difference between now and August is that in August, there was a multitude of days with exceptionally odd breadth readings. Some of the biggest stocks were masking underlying weakness. Combined with heavy speculative activity, it was a dangerous setup.

Now, we've seen very strong internal strength, in the broad market, as well as tech and small-cap stocks. Prior signals almost invariably led to higher prices. That's hard to square with the idea that forward returns tend to be subdued when Confidence is high, but that's less reliable during healthy market conditions, which we're seeing now (for the most part).

I added some risk with small-cap energy stocks, due to an increasing number of positive signs in both small-caps and energy. This is intended as a long-term position.


RETURN YTD:  -2.5%

2019: 12.6%, 2018: 0.6%, 2017: 3.8%, 2016: 17.1%, 2015: 9.2%, 2014: 14.5%, 2013: 2.2%, 2012: 10.8%, 2011: 16.5%, 2010: 15.3%, 2009: 23.9%, 2008: 16.2%, 2007: 7.8%

Phase Table

Click here to view the Phase Table on the site.

Ranks

Click here to view on the site (Ranks tab on the Dashboard).

Sentiment Around The World

Click here to view on the site.

Optimism Index Thumbnails

Sector ETF's - 10-Day Moving Average
Country ETF's - 10-Day Moving Average
Bond ETF's - 10-Day Moving Average
Currency ETF's - 5-Day Moving Average
Commodity ETF's - 5-Day Moving Average

Sorry, you don't have access to this report

Upgrade your subscription plan to get access
Go to Dasboard
DATA &
TECHnologies
IndicatorEdge
‍
BackTestEdge
‍
Other Tools
‍
DataEdge API
RESEARCH
reports
Research Solution
‍
Reports Library
‍
actionable
Strategies
Trading Strategies
‍
Smart Stock Scanner
‍
FREE
RESOUrCES
Simple Backtest
Calculator
Simple Seasonality
Calculator
The Kelly Criterion
Calculator
Sentiment Geo Map
‍
Public Research Reports
‍
Free Webinar
COMPANY
‍
About
‍
Meet our Team
‍
In the News
‍
Testimonials
‍
Client Success Stories
Pricing
Bundle pricing
‍
Announcements
‍
FAQ
© 2024 Sundial Capital Research Inc. All rights reserved.
Setsail Marketing
TermsPrivacyAffiliate Program
Risk Disclosure: Futures and forex trading contains substantial risk and is not for every investor. An investor could potentially lose all or more than the initial investment. Risk capital is money that can be lost without jeopardizing ones’ financial security or life style. Only risk capital should be used for trading and only those with sufficient risk capital should consider trading. Past performance is not necessarily indicative of future results.

Hypothetical Performance Disclosure: Hypothetical performance results have many inherent limitations, some of which are described below. No representation is being made that any account will or is likely to achieve profits or losses similar to those shown; in fact, there are frequently sharp differences between hypothetical performance results and the actual results subsequently achieved by any particular trading program. One of the limitations of hypothetical performance results is that they are generally prepared with the benefit of hindsight. In addition, hypothetical trading does not involve financial risk, and no hypothetical trading record can completely account for the impact of financial risk of actual trading. for example, the ability to withstand losses or to adhere to a particular trading program in spite of trading losses are material points which can also adversely affect actual trading results. There are numerous other factors related to the markets in general or to the implementation of any specific trading program which cannot be fully accounted for in the preparation of hypothetical performance results and all which can adversely affect trading results.

Testimonial Disclosure: Testimonials appearing on this website may not be representative of other clients or customers and is not a guarantee of future performance or success.