Rally in gold miners falters as gains outstripped metal's surge

Monique Mulima
October 18, 2025 at 12:00 AM UTC

In a recent Bloomberg article, SentimenTrader's senior research analyst Jay Kaeppel noted that traders holding long positions in the SPDR Gold Trust ETF (GLD) face a key decision after gold's historic rally — "take profits" or "let it ride." The comments

In a recent Bloomberg article, SentimenTrader's senior research analyst Jay Kaeppel noted that traders holding long positions in the SPDR Gold Trust ETF (GLD) face a key decision after gold's historic rally - "take profits" or "let it ride." The comments followed one of the sharpest pullbacks in months for gold miners, as the NYSE Arca Gold Miners Index tumbled 6% while bullion slipped 2%. 

According to Kaeppel's analysis in Kaeppel's Corner, gold's surge has created a classic dilemma: lock in gains or hedge for potential volatility. He highlighted that options strategies, such as ratio collars, can allow traders to stay partially invested while capping downside risk. 

 Bloomberg also noted that gold's recent advance has outpaced the underlying metal, with leading miners like Newmont, Agnico Eagle, and Barrick each up more than 100% this year compared with gold's 60% rise. By contrast, investors who adopted hedging or partial-profit-taking approaches during similar periods historically preserved more of their gains once volatility returned.  

While each cycle has its own drivers, Kaeppel emphasized that discipline matters most when optimism runs high. For traders seeking to balance risk and reward, he wrote, a structured hedge "can make great sense - but only if you're prepared to handle the psychology that comes with it."  

For Jay Kaeppel's full analysis and options breakdown, visit SentimenTrader.com